Management, Personality and Organizational Culture: When Governance Quietly Turns Toxic

Governance is often understood as a set of formal rules, procedures, and reporting mechanisms designed to ensure accountability within complex institutions. Yet in practice, governance also unfolds through informal relationships, shared assumptions, and unspoken norms that shape how decisions are made long before they are officially validated.

Some time ago, I was invited to attend, as an external advisor, a working session within a large multilateral organization. Around the table sat senior managers representing different national cultures, which is hardly unusual in institutions operating across borders in areas such as development, humanitarian aid, or international cooperation.

At first glance, everything appeared perfectly normal. The tone was courteous, the exchanges measured, and the atmosphere aligned with what one would expect from an experienced leadership team accustomed to working under political and financial constraints. Yet what struck me most that day was not what was said, but what remained unsaid.

The discussion moved forward in an oddly constrained way. Participants spoke in turn, but without real engagement. Questions were asked, though never pursued. No one openly disagreed, yet no one seemed genuinely convinced either. Beneath the surface of institutional politeness, one could sense a diffuse unease: bodies leaning back at decisive moments, eyes briefly turning away, and an almost palpable hesitation whenever the conversation approached anything resembling a challenge.

It gradually became clear that the meeting was not intended to reach a decision, but to formalize one that had already been taken elsewhere.

The Ritual of Participation

The item on the agenda concerned the approval of salary increases for a number of staff members. Human Resources had circulated a set of documents which, despite their length, offered surprisingly little in the way of substantive performance analysis. The recommendations presented by the relevant line manager relied instead on more informal considerations: loyalty, reliability, perceived commitment to the team, or simply ease of collaboration.

A short exchange followed, although its outcome seemed predetermined from the outset. In the end, the decision emerged from a discussion between three individuals — the Director, the Head of Human Resources, and the manager directly concerned — while the other attendees remained present but functionally silent.

Their role was not to contribute to the deliberation, but to witness it. One might even say that their presence served primarily to confer an appearance of procedural legitimacy on a process whose conclusion had already been decided upstream.

This type of situation is by no means exceptional. It reflects a recurring paradox within large institutions whose external mission is to promote fairness, accountability, or social development, yet whose internal functioning often relies on opaque and highly discretionary forms of authority.

The Quiet Logic of Informal Power

Seen from the outside, such decisions may appear arbitrary or even unjust. Yet they are rarely experienced as such by those who make them. Within complex organizational environments, maintaining trust and alignment within a leadership team is often perceived as essential to institutional stability.

In contexts marked by funding uncertainty, political pressure, or reputational risk, managers may come to rely less on formal evaluation criteria than on relational confidence as a basis for decision-making. The question becomes not only who performs well, but who can be counted on in moments of crisis.

This is where psychological dynamics come into play. As Maslow’s work reminds us, the search for influence frequently reflects a deeper need for security. At the same time, Schwartz’s theory of values suggests that leadership behavior is shaped by a tension between the desire for individual recognition and the equally powerful need to preserve continuity within the organization.

When these underlying motivations remain implicit, they tend to structure decisions in ways that are neither discussed nor examined. Cultural differences may influence communication styles or expectations, but they do not, in themselves, determine the quality of governance. What matters far more is the capacity of leaders to reflect on their own assumptions and to consider the systemic effects of their choices.

Authority Is Not Legitimacy

In the short term, discretionary decisions of this kind may strengthen authority or reinforce internal alliances. Over time, however, they often produce less visible but more damaging consequences. Employees who perceive that advancement depends less on contribution than on alignment are likely to disengage, if not openly, then through a gradual withdrawal of initiative.

The organization may continue to function, but with diminishing coherence. Collaboration becomes more cautious, responsibility more diffuse, and innovation increasingly risky. Trust erodes quietly, not through conflict, but through the accumulation of small inconsistencies between declared values and lived experience.

It would be a mistake to interpret these outcomes as the result of individual ill will. More often than not, they reflect structural blind spots within governance systems that privilege control over dialogue and predictability over adaptation.

Towards a More Conscious Form of Governance

Traditional leadership development programs tend to focus on communication skills or behavioral competencies, which can certainly improve day-to-day interactions. Yet they rarely address the deeper interplay between values, informal norms, and power relations that ultimately shape institutional decisions.

In a world characterized by growing complexity — whether driven by climate risk, technological transformation, or geopolitical instability — organizations are increasingly called upon to navigate uncertainty without sacrificing coherence. This requires forms of leadership capable not only of deciding, but of making sense of competing perspectives and integrating them into a shared direction.

Such a shift implies moving from governance understood primarily as the exercise of authority toward governance conceived as a process of collective understanding. It involves creating the conditions under which decisions can be questioned without being undermined, and disagreements expressed without being perceived as threats.

This, in turn, demands time, trust, and a willingness to confront the anxieties that often accompany change.

From Position to Legitimacy

Institutional authority may derive from mandate or position. Leadership legitimacy, however, emerges from the perceived alignment between declared principles and internal practices.

As international organizations confront increasingly complex challenges, their credibility will depend not only on the outcomes they deliver, but also on the integrity of the processes through which those outcomes are achieved.

In this sense, conscious governance is less an ethical ideal than a practical necessity for institutions seeking to remain effective — and credible — in a rapidly evolving environment.

Interested in Reflecting on Your Organization’s Governance Practices?

If your institution is currently navigating leadership transitions, internal tensions, or the challenges of decision-making in complex environments, it may be time to step back and examine how informal dynamics, values, and organizational culture are shaping outcomes — often more powerfully than formal procedures.

At Carrio Strategy Partners, we work with NGOs, foundations, and public-sector organizations to help leadership teams better understand the relational and systemic factors that influence governance, trust, and institutional effectiveness.

To explore whether a reflective advisory process could support your organization at this stage, you are welcome to get in touch:


👉 Click here to contact me

References

Argyris, C. (1991). Teaching smart people how to learn. Harvard Business Review, 69(3), 99–109.
https://hbr.org/1991/05/teaching-smart-people-how-to-learn

Edmondson, A. C. (2019). The fearless organization: Creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. Wiley.
https://www.wiley.com/en-us/The+Fearless+Organization-p-9781119477242

Hofstede, G. (2001). Culture’s consequences: Comparing values, behaviors, institutions and organizations across nations (2nd ed.). Sage Publications.
https://doi.org/10.4135/9781452231598

Maslow, A. H. (1943). A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review, 50(4), 370–396.
https://doi.org/10.1037/h0054346

Schwartz, S. H. (1992). Universals in the content and structure of values: Theoretical advances and empirical tests in 20 countries. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 25, 1–65.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0065-2601(08)60281-6

Schein, E. H. (2010). Organizational culture and leadership (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass.
https://www.wiley.com/en-us/Organizational+Culture+and+Leadership%2C+4th+Edition-p-9780470190609

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *