Why Decision-making Seems Hard
Some decisions yield to analysis. Choosing between two insurance policies, comparing investment options, or selecting a supplier can be approached rationally: information gathered, alternatives compared, probabilities estimated.
Major life decisions rarely follow the same logic.
A career transition, a move abroad, the launch of a business, the end of a long-standing commitment — these involve layers of complexity that no list of pros and cons can fully capture.
Part of this complexity arises from three forces operating simultaneously: what pulls from the past through habits, loyalties, and previously acquired beliefs; what constrains in the present through practical realities; and what presses from the future — a possibility not yet fully formed, but seeming to seek expression through unexpected encounters, obstacles, and openings.
Research in complexity theory suggests that living systems evolve through processes that cannot be entirely predicted from current conditions. Otto Scharmer\’s foundational work on presencing develops this intuition further: attention, he argues, may be directed not only toward the past that conditions our perception, but toward future possibilities that seek manifestation through present experience.
Within such situations, the challenge is no longer simply to determine what is desirable. It becomes a question of discerning what is trying to emerge.
Weak Signals: When Meaning Appears Before Understanding
The concept of weak signals originates in strategic foresight. Researchers observed that major changes are typically preceded by subtle early indications — ones that initially appear insignificant, and whose implications only become clear in retrospect.
Something analogous occurs during periods of personal transformation.
Before a significant change becomes visible, a different kind of data begins to accumulate: a recurring dream, an unexpected coincidence, a persistent intuition, an emotional reaction seemingly disproportionate to the situation, or a bodily sensation that reliably accompanies a particular thought.
This is not mysticism. It has a scientific basis.
Eugene Gendlin\’s concept of the felt sense and Antonio Damasio\’s research on somatic markers both demonstrate that human beings register information before consciously understanding it. A feeling of constriction in the chest, a knot in the stomach, an unexplained fatigue — these may represent forms of implicit knowing rather than mere emotional noise.
Carl Jung explored related phenomena through his concept of synchronicity — not to posit mysterious causal mechanisms, but to investigate the possibility that certain events become connected through meaning rather than through physical causation.
None of this implies that every intuition is correct. It suggests that decision-making involves dimensions of experience not accessible through analytical reasoning alone — and that ignoring them carries its own risks.
Why Symbolic Systems Have Always Mattered
Throughout history, human beings have developed symbolic systems to organize experience and explore meaning: mythology, ritual, dream interpretation, sacred texts. From a psychological perspective, these are best understood not as belief systems but as cognitive tools — structured frameworks that help bring implicit knowledge into conscious awareness.
Two such systems — Tarot and Kabbalah — operate according to different but complementary principles and deserve particular attention here.
A tarot reading begins with images: archetypal situations, psychological dynamics, developmental challenges. Meaning emerges through dialogue between the image and the person contemplating it. The movement is from experience toward understanding.
Kabbalah approaches the same territory differently. Rather than images, it investigates relationships between structures, numbers, letters, and levels of meaning. It introduces the possibility that meaning also flows in the opposite direction — not only from experience upward, but from deeper structural patterns downward into lived situations.
The classical Kabbalistic model of the Tree of Life reflects this: a dynamic circulation between levels of existence, movements of manifestation and return, form and essence.
Together, the two systems are complementary. Tarot illuminates what is happening within experience. Kabbalah investigates the deeper structures through which meaning may be unfolding.
The Four Levels of PaRDeS: A Decision-Making Framework
One of Kabbalah\’s most practically useful contributions is a model of interpretation known as PaRDeS — meaning \”orchard\” — which describes four levels of reading any situation.
Peshat — the literal level. Start with observable facts. What is actually happening? What information is available? What constraints exist? Any interpretation disconnected from this level risks becoming projection.
Remez — hints and indications. Here weak signals become relevant. Dreams, synchronicities, recurring sensations, and meaningful coincidences are not treated as answers but as invitations to inquiry.
Derash — interpretation. The various elements are placed within a broader narrative. Psychological patterns, personal history, values, and motivations become visible. The question shifts from \”What is happening?\” to \”What might this situation mean?\”
Sod — the deeper layer. Numbers, letters, and symbolic correspondences become tools of inquiry. The goal is not prediction but the gradual unveiling of meaning that was not initially accessible.
What makes PaRDeS useful as a decision-making framework is precisely that it begins with facts — and only then opens progressively toward deeper layers of meaning. It is a discipline of attention, not an escape from reality.
A Practical Example of Decision-Making
Consider a professional who receives an attractive proposal.
Rationally, the opportunity appears highly desirable: strong visibility, stimulating collaborations, promising prospects. Yet each time she thinks about accepting, a subtle unease appears. An unexpected fatigue. Conversations about the project leave behind confusion rather than clarity. The body is reluctant even though the mind remains interested.
At Peshat, the first task is factual: What exactly is being offered? What responsibilities are implied? What expectations remain unstated?
At Remez, the recurring discomfort becomes significant data. The fatigue, the confusion, the persistent feeling that \”something is off\” — these are weak signals. They do not indicate that the opportunity should be refused. They indicate that the situation deserves closer examination.
At Derash, a tarot reading repeatedly produces two Major Arcana: Justice and the Hermit. One possible interpretation involves themes of discernment, introspection, and the need to withdraw from external pressure before deciding. The tarot does not answer the question. It reframes it.
At Sod, the Kabbalistic exploration begins. Justice corresponds to 8, the Hermit to 9. Together: 17. In Hebrew numerology, 17 corresponds to Tov (טוב) — \”goodness.\” But the inquiry continues into the word\’s three constituent letters: Tet (ט), associated with hidden potential not yet manifested; Vav (ו), a connector, a bridge; Bet (ב), a house, a container, a space within which something takes form.
Whether these associations are read literally, psychologically, or structurally matters less than what they produce: a transformation of the original question.
The question began as: Should I accept this project?
The symbolic process gradually reveals different questions — ones that are actually more useful:
- What hidden potential might be seeking expression through this opportunity?
- What relationship requires clarification before a decision can be responsibly made?
- Does the unease arise from the project itself, or from something in the surrounding situation that remains poorly understood?
This is the value of symbolic inquiry: not prediction, but the revelation of dimensions of meaning that were not initially visible.
What Transpersonal Psychology Adds in Decision-Making Process
This attention to intuition, symbolism, and emergence finds rigorous grounding in transpersonal psychology.
The work of Abraham Maslow, Stanislav Grof, Roger Walsh, Frances Vaughan, and Jorge Ferrer reflects a sustained research interest in dimensions of human experience that extend beyond conventional cognitive models — including meaning, intuition, symbolic perception, and transformative experience.
Within this framework, systems like Tarot and Kabbalah are not predictive technologies. Their value lies in providing structured frameworks for exploring complexity — tools that skilled practitioners have refined over centuries precisely because they work.
This also resonates strongly with Scharmer\’s concept of an emerging future. A decision, viewed through this lens, is not merely a choice between alternatives. It is participation in a process through which new possibilities gradually become visible.
Listening to What Is Trying to Emerge
Major decisions rarely involve facts alone.
They arise at the intersection of personal history, present constraints, bodily experience, symbolic meaning, and future possibility. Weak signals do not eliminate uncertainty. Tarot does not predict the future. Kabbalah does not provide definitive answers.
Their contribution lies elsewhere: they create conditions for deeper inquiry.
Perhaps the most useful question is therefore not \”What should I do?\”
But: \”What is this situation trying to reveal?\”
Between the facts of the present and the possibilities of the future, a space of meaning opens. It is within that space that some of life\’s most important decisions gradually — and reliably — take shape.
If you are navigating a complex decision — one where the facts are clear but something still feels unresolved — I work with executives and leaders to bring that deeper layer into focus.
References
Damasio, A. (1994). Descartes\’ Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain. Putnam. — Google Scholar
Ferrer, J. N. (2002). Revisioning Transpersonal Theory. SUNY Press. — SUNY Press
Gendlin, E. T. (1981). Focusing. Bantam Books. — The Focusing Institute
Grof, S. (2000). Psychology of the Future. SUNY Press. — SUNY Press
Jung, C. G. (1973). Synchronicity: An Acausal Connecting Principle. Princeton University Press. — Princeton University Press
Scharmer, O. (2009). Theory U: Leading from the Future as It Emerges. Berrett-Koehler. — Presencing Institute
Scholem, G. (1965). On the Kabbalah and Its Symbolism. Schocken Books. — Google Scholar

