Humanistic Leadership has become one of the most seductive narratives in contemporary management. Yesterday, I attended a workshop on the topic of “calling.” The facilitators invited us to reflect on how our work benefits others — colleagues, customers, and even future generations.
On the surface, it sounded inspiring. Yet, as I listened, a deep unease began to grow in me. How can we speak of calling — an inner vocation, an act of soul — in a system where most people sell their time to organizations whose primary purpose is profit, control, or survival? How can “service” be authentic when the framework itself is based on dependency and exchange?
After nearly fifty years in leadership — having created my first company at 25 and later worked across corporate, public, and non-profit sectors — I’ve seen many managerial myths rise and fall: the hero-leader, the “shared values” era of participatory management, and now the humanistic turn. The language changes; the asymmetry rarely does.
Humanistic Leadership and the Soft Power of Meaning
The vocabulary of calling, service, and purpose has become the new grammar of control. It no longer belongs to the sacred; it belongs to performance psychology.
In the past, managers motivated through fear or competition. Today, they motivate through meaning — turning inner purpose into organizational fuel.
Erich Fromm warned that the modern individual can be “free” while being subtly conditioned to desire what the system needs (Fromm, 1941/1970). That is precisely what happens when the spiritual notion of calling is absorbed by institutions: it becomes an instrument of moral persuasion.
We stop asking, “What is my soul calling me to do?” and replace it with, “How can I make my company’s mission feel like my calling?” The difference seems subtle — it changes everything.
The Illusion of Altruism
The workshop’s message was clear: those who serve others are more effective and fulfilled than those who serve themselves.
It sounds noble, but it rests on a false duality. Authentic service is not a horizontal opposition (self vs. others); it is a vertical movement:
- Know your mission and place.
- Understand your environment and its rules.
- Act consciously in service of a cause freely chosen.
Without that inner grounding, “serving others” easily becomes self-betrayal — a search for approval, security, or belonging. Then service becomes compliance in moral clothing.
As James Hillman insists, a calling is “a necessity of the soul,” not a job description (Hillman, 1996). Humanistic Leadership risks confusing obedience with vocation.
Humanistic Leadership or Ethical Camouflage?
Workplaces have become moral theaters. We are told to bring our “whole selves,” to speak of empathy, authenticity, and purpose. Underneath, the structure remains transactional: some sell time; others extract value.
Saying “we care about people” is cheap; sharing power is costly.
In the non-profit and public sectors, the currency isn’t profit but symbolic power — legitimacy, prestige, control of narratives. Altruism becomes hierarchy by other means. I have witnessed this too often to ignore it.
Humanistic Leadership presents itself as a remedy — re-humanizing organizations with ethics and meaning. But unless we question the architecture of domination, humanism can become ethical camouflage.
It comforts managers with moral prestige and comforts employees with significance — a perfect system of co-dependency wrapped in care.
We have effectively inverted Maslow: rather than meeting material needs to enable self-actualization, we now demand self-actualization to justify relentless productivity (Maslow, 1962).
The result: exhaustion disguised as purpose, alienation disguised as vocation, a muted grief beneath slogans about meaning. Viktor Frankl reminds us that humans are destroyed not by suffering, but by suffering without meaning (Frankl, 1959). Yet meaning cannot be manufactured by HR; it arises from consciousness, not from culture decks.
Spiritual Capitalism and the Vertical Understanding of Vocation
True vocation does not originate in corporate culture, HR workshops, or institutional missions. It arises from a vertical relationship to life — between the person and something larger: soul, truth, the living cosmos.
This is close to Spinoza’s conatus: each being strives to persist and increase its power of acting (Ethics, 1677). When vocation aligns with this increase in potentia, service flows without self-erasure.
Likewise, Aristotle framed human flourishing (eudaimonia) as the realization of one’s telos through virtuous activity (Nicomachean Ethics). Service, then, is not a managerial KPI; it’s a coherent expression of one’s purpose within the world.
And the Stoics (Epictetus) would add: the only true servitude is to what lies outside our control; the only true freedom is inner sovereignty.
This vertical vision does not reject organizations; it simply refuses to be absorbed by them. One can hold a salaried role without outsourcing one’s source of meaning. The criterion is simple: does my work increase or diminish my power to act lucidly, justly, and creatively?
Toward Conscious Service and True Humanism
It is time to reclaim service from the rhetoric of efficiency. Service is not being useful; service is being true.
It is the act of aligning one’s life with a higher coherence rather than with external approval. Serving others and serving oneself are not opposites; they are moments on the same axis. We rise inwardly to act outwardly.
The humanism we need will not be corporate. It will be conscious, vertical, and free — arising from individuals who refuse to confuse obedience with purpose or vocation with productivity.
In profit-driven firms, service risks becoming moral fuel for the machine; in non-profits, it can become symbolic currency for power. In both, the antidote is the same: interiority, discernment, and limits.
Closing Thought
Leaving the Humanistic Leadership Academy session, I felt both grateful and unsettled. Grateful, because the longing for meaning is real. Unsettled, because that longing is easily captured to sustain systems that mute it.
Perhaps the urgent task of leadership today is not to make organizations “more human,” but to help humans become less dependent on organizations to remember who they are.
References
- Aristotle. (trans. various). Nicomachean Ethics.
- Epictetus. (trans. various). Enchiridion and Discourses.
- Frankl, V. E. (1959). Man’s Search for Meaning. Beacon Press.
- Fromm, E. (1941/1970). Escape from Freedom (also published as The Fear of Freedom). Holt / Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- Hillman, J. (1996). The Soul’s Code: In Search of Character and Calling. Random House.
- Maslow, A. H. (1962). Toward a Psychology of Being. Van Nostrand.
- Spinoza, B. de. (1677). Ethics, Demonstrated in Geometrical Order.
- Zohar, D., & Marshall, I. (2004). Spiritual Capital: Wealth We Can Live By. Berrett-Koehler.
- Hurst, A. (2014). The Purpose Economy. Elevate.
Leadership is evolving. Are you?
At CarrioStrategyPartners.com, we work with leaders and organizations ready to awaken higher intelligence — strategic, emotional, and spiritual.
→ Schedule a conversation today.
Further Reading / Academic References
Keller, J. G. (2008). Spirituality, Economics, and Education: A Dialogic Critique of “Spiritual Capital.” Retrieved from PhilArchive.
Coudert, A. P. (2023). The Religion of Consumer Capitalism and the Construction of Spiritual Market-Subjects. Religions, 14(6), 750. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel14060750
Watts, G. (2023). Purification or Pollution? The Debate over “Workplace Spirituality.” Journal of Management, Spirituality & Religion. https://doi.org/10.1177/17499755221108607
Taira, T. (2009). The Problem of Capitalism in the Scholarship on Contemporary Spirituality. Scripta, 2, 11-27. https://journal.fi/scripta/article/view/67353
Ul-Haq, S. (2020). Spiritual Development and Meaningful Work. Journal of Management, Spirituality & Religion. https://doi.org/10.1080/13678868.2019.167957

